A Silent Betrayal: Whistleblowing Within the Portuguese Canadian Community

This article is sponsored by:

The story of Portuguese immigration to Canada is often told through examples of hard work, resilience, and community solidarity. Arriving with little more than determination, many Portuguese families relied on each other to find housing, jobs, and a sense of belonging. Mutual aid was key to survival in unfamiliar territory. Yet, beneath the surface of this cooperation, there is a lesser-known reality: some members of the Portuguese community reported undocumented immigrants to Canadian authorities, leading to arrests, deportations, and lasting fear.

In the 1970s, a Portuguese tobacco farmer in Southwestern Ontario became known among some in the community for monitoring the presence of undocumented workers. According to a source that we cannot name, he would drive to construction sites and farms, strike up conversations, and quietly collect information. Afterward, he would contact immigration officials, who often responded with raids and deportations. The source himself was deported following the farmer’s whistleblowing.

While some may have seen this as a civic responsibility or an attempt to protect their own legal status, the impact on undocumented individuals and their families was significant and, in many cases, traumatic.

The trend did not stop with one individual or a single decade. In the 1980s, there were further cases of immigration raids connected to tips from within the community. One such event affected my father in 1985 who, at the time, had not yet begun his immigration process. After being alerted to a raid at his residence, he took a different route home and managed to avoid arrest. Others in the same household were not as fortunate. As a result of this episode, my father was forced to move and lived with the constant fear of a knock at the door, a fear shared by many Portuguese who had overstayed their welcome or entered the country through informal means in search of a better life.

In a recent article publish here about the life of José Higino Carvalho, a Portuguese man who worked in Canada without legal status for some time, it was revealed that his workplace was raided by immigration officials following a report made by someone known to the victims. Stories like Carvalho’s were not isolated incidents but part of a broader, uncomfortable pattern. These acts of whistleblowing created a sense of mistrust within immigrant circles and added to the challenges already faced by those living in legal limbo.

Another documented case involves a Portuguese national repeatedly deported and re-entering Canada illegally. One individual was deported five times before finally being denied entry—despite family ties in Canada . Although the reporting source isn’t specified, such patterns suggest the involvement of official tips or surveillance in immigration enforcement within the community.

While it’s difficult to know the motivations behind each case – whether jealousy, personal disputes, fear of legal consequences, or a belief in following the law – the  result was a breakdown in the solidarity that many relied on to survive. The actions of a few had long-lasting consequences for many, damaging trust in a community that otherwise prided itself on standing together in a foreign land.

This lesser-discussed chapter in Portuguese Canadian history deserves more attention. It highlights the complex social dynamics within immigrant communities and reminds us that hardship does not always bring unity. As Canada continues to reflect on its immigration policies and multicultural identity, it’s important to remember not just the stories of success, but also those of internal conflict and betrayal. Only by acknowledging the full picture can we understand the past and work toward a future where solidarity is stronger than fear and where community is more important than individual agendas.

Do you have a similar a story about whistleblowing within the community. If so, please contact us.